Visualizing “ObamaCare-related” Job Cuts

UPDATE: Added some extra visualization elements since this post went live. New select menu and hover text for individual job impact detail lines in the table.

I was reviewing RSS feeds when I came across this story about “ObamaCare Employer Mandate: A List Of Cuts To Work Hours, Jobs” over on Efficacy of the law notwithstanding, I thought it might be interesting to visualize the data since the folks over at provided a handy spreadsheet that they seem to maintain pretty well (link is in the article).

The spreadsheet is organized by date and lists each state where the jobs were impacted along with the employer, employer type (public/private), reason and number of jobs impacted (if available). They also have links to news stories related to each entry.

My first thought was to compare impact across states by date, so I threw together a quick R script to build a faceted bar chart:

# Source for job impact data:
emp.f <- read.csv("~/employers.csv", stringsAsFactors=FALSE)
colnames(emp.f) <- c("State","Employer","Type","Action","Jobs.Cut","Action.Date")
emp.f[$Jobs.Cut),]$Jobs.Cut = median(emp.f$Jobs.Cut, na.rm=TRUE)
emp.f[emp.f$State=="Virgina", ]$State = "Virginia"
emp.f[emp.f$State=="Washington DC", ]$State = "District of Columbia"

Yes, they really spelled “Virginia” wrong, at least in the article text where I initially scraped the data from before I saw there was a spreadsheet available. Along with fixing “Virginia”, I also changed the name of “Washington DC” to “District of Columbia” for reasons you’ll see later on in this post. I’m finding it very helpful to do as much of the data cleanup in-code (R or Python) whenever possible since it makes the process far more repeatable than performing the same tasks by hand in a text editor and is essential if you know the data is going to change/expand.

After reading in the data, it was trivial to get a ggplot of the job impacts by state (click image for larger version):

p <- ggplot(emp.f, aes(x=Action.Date, y=Jobs.Cut))
p <- p + geom_bar(aes(fill=State), stat="identity")
p <- p + facet_wrap(~State)
p <- p + theme_bw()
p <- p + theme(legend.position=0, axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 90))
p <- p + labs(x="Action Date", y="# Jobs Cut")


That visualization provided some details, but I decided to expand the scope a bit and wanted to make an interactive “bubble chart” (since folks seem to love bubbles) with circle size relative to the total job cuts per state and circle color reflecting the conservative/liberal leaning of each state (i.e. ‘red’ vs ‘blue’) to see if there was any visual correlation by that attribute. I found the political data over at Gallup and went to work prepping the data with some additional R code. (NOTE: The Gallup data was the reason for the “DC” name change since Gallup uses “District of Columbia” in their data set.)

# aggregate state data
emp.state.sum.df <- count(emp.f,c("State"),c("Jobs.Cut"))
colnames(emp.state.sum.df) <- c("State","Total.Jobs.Cut")
# get total (estimated) jobs impacted <- sum(emp.state.sum.df$Total.Jobs.Cut)
# Source for the red v blue state data:
# read political leanings <- read.csv("~/red-blue.csv", stringsAsFactors=FALSE)
# join the jobs and leaning data together
s <- join(emp.state.sum.df,, by="State")
# cheat and get leaning range for manual input into the datavis
leaning.range <- range(s$Conservative.Advantage)
# build the JSON data file. store state summary data for the bubbles, but also include
# the detail level for extra data for the viz
# need to clean up this file post-write and definitely run it through
jsfile = file("states.tmp","w")
by(s, 1:nrow(s), function(row) {
  writeLines(sprintf('      {"name": "%s", "size":%d, "leaning":%2.1f, "detail":[',row$State,row$Total.Jobs.Cut,row$Conservative.Advantage),jsfile)
  employers = emp.f[emp.f$State == row$State,]
  by(employers, 1:nrow(employers), function(emp.row) {
    writeLines(sprintf('          { "employer":"%s", "emptype":"%s", "actiondetail":"%s", "jobsimpacted":%d, "when":"%s"},',
                       emp.row$Employer, emp.row$Type, gsub('"',"'",emp.row$Action), emp.row$Jobs.Cut, emp.row$Action.Date),jsfile)

I know the comments point out the need to tweak the resulting JSON a bit (mostly to remove “errant” commas, which is one of the annoying bits about JSON), but I wanted to re-emphasize the huge utility of JSONlint as it can save you a great deal of time debugging large amounts of gnarly JSON data.

With the data prepped, I threw together a D3 visualization that shows the bubbles on the left and details by date and employer on the right.


Since it’s D3, there’s no need to put the source code in the blog post. Just do a “view-source” on the resulting visualization or poke around the github repository. I will, however, point out a couple useful/interesting bits from the code.

First, coloring circles by political leaning took exactly one line of code since D3 provides a means to map a range of values to colors:

var ramp = d3.scale.linear().domain([-21,36]).range(["#253494","#B30000"]);

I chose the colors with Color Brewer but cheated (as I indicated in the R code) by pre-computing the range of the values for the palette. You can see the tiny District of Columbia’s very blue circle in the lower-left of the field of circles. Hopefully will maintain the data set and we can look at changes over a larger period of time.

Second, you get rudimentary “popups” for free via element “title” tags on the SVG circles, so no need for custom tooltip code:

   .text(function(d) { return d.stateName + ": " + format(d.value) + " jobs impacted"; });

I could have tweaked the display a bit more, added links to the stories and provided a means to sort the “# Jobs” column by count or date, but I took enough time away from the book to scratch this visualization itch and it came out pretty much the way I wanted it to.

If you do hack at it and build something better (which should not be terribly difficult), drop a note in the comments or over at github.

Cover image from Data-Driven Security
Amazon Author Page

1 Comment Visualizing “ObamaCare-related” Job Cuts

  1. Mathew Woodyard

    This post inspires me to step up my d3 game. As one is wont to do when examining data visualizations, I hovered over the state in which I live. I found it sad and humorous to find that the LDS Church is cutting hours for some who work for their own nonprofit (Deseret Industries). Sometimes you need to be really, really sure your charity isn’t providing healthcare to people.

    All that to say, you’ve made a great data visualization that does what it’s supposed to. I found this much easier to navigate than the source you linked to and it was a delight to explore.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.